Quantcast
Channel: Comments on: The Dangers of Non-Modeled Narrative Story Tellers
Browsing all 13 articles
Browse latest View live

By: Barry Ritholtz

capitalistic: Remember George Box’s corollary: “All models are wrong, but some are useful.”

View Article



By: Bokolis

A little narrative about the yard signs as it may apply to a swing state… In Pennsylvania, or at least the parts I frequent, you typically see yard signs for every office under the sun (and then some);...

View Article

By: RW

Stories can get you into big gains or big troubles or nothing at all and oddly enough it doesn’t seem to be related to how good a story it is but how well it translates the world. George Steiner’s...

View Article

By: Barry Ritholtz

BTW, I’ve referenced this repeatedly in the “Monkeys love a Narrative” comments over the years, as well as “Your Brain On Stocks” presentation I have been giving the past 18 months

View Article

By: rd

As an engineer, my basic rule on narratives is that a good narrative can help people accept reality but it won’t save them from reality. People are often led down the wrong road by somebody spinning a...

View Article


By: Monday links: entertaining narratives - Abnormal Returns | Abnormal Returns

[...] Barry Ritholtz, “Investors need to remember this whenever they are told a story. Narrative may be entertaining, but they won’t make you money.”  (Big Picture) [...]

View Article

By: faulkner

The title and concepts contained within Donald Spence’s 1984 book “Narrative Truth and Historical Truth” are an early summary of your points (and later developments in narrative studies). Effective...

View Article

By: pmorrisonfl

> rd: One of the primary reasons the Challenger blew up… Very relevant and pertinent example. Feynman’s report (http://www.ralentz.com/old/space/feynman-report.html), an appendix to the Rogers...

View Article


By: slowkarma

I think you’re absolutely correct in your general argument. Specifically, though…Nate Silver can explain statistical arguments, but his book was full of simple grammatical and structural (writing)...

View Article


By: slowkarma

And here’s a Barry story we really need — they way Mac software runs this word correction program that **never gets the right word.** In my comment above, there are three misspellings, generated by...

View Article

By: jonas

BR, I think you’re too harsh on narratives. If you redefine narratives to only mean the bad ones, then sure Nate Silver is not only selling narratives. But his explanatory style is a big part to his...

View Article

By: Weekend reading: Festive fun

[...] Beware of a good story – The Big Picture [...]

View Article

By: Rise of the Empiricists | The Big Picture

[...] The Dangers of Non-Modeled Narrative Story Tellers (December 3rd, 2012) [...]

View Article

Browsing all 13 articles
Browse latest View live




Latest Images